Judge denies 'stand your ground' claim by man who shot Savannah teen canvassing for Warnock

Javontae Vann, who was shot while canvassing for U.S. Sen. Raphael Warnock in December 2022, said the shooting has not put a damper on his enthusiasm for politics: “It makes me feel as if there's more that needs to be done." (Jake Shore/The Current)

A Chatham County judge denied a “stand your ground” claim by the man accused of shooting a Black teenager who had approached his door in December 2022 while canvassing for U.S. Sen. Raphael Warnock.

In a ruling on Monday, Superior Court Judge Penny Freesemann said there was not enough evidence to support that Jimmy Paiz, 44, acted in self-defense and reasonably felt threatened by the politically-active 15-year-old, who was trying to convince Savannah voters on Dec. 1, 2022, to turn out for Warnock’s tight runoff election against Herschel Walker.

At the hearing, attorneys for Paiz, a Honduran-American veteran and writer, showed security footage from the incident to claim that the 6-foot-tall teenager and canvasser, Javontae Vann, tried to use the doorknob to get into Paiz’s house and that Paiz felt reasonably threatened.